This forum uses cookies
This forum makes use of cookies to store your login information if you are registered, and your last visit if you are not. Cookies are small text documents stored on your computer; the cookies set by this forum can only be used on this website and pose no security risk. Cookies on this forum also track the specific topics you have read and when you last read them. Please confirm whether you accept or reject these cookies being set.

A cookie will be stored in your browser regardless of choice to prevent you being asked this question again. You will be able to change your cookie settings at any time using the link in the footer.

Forum stats Reload
Latest posts
TopicDate, time Last SenderForum
  Congratulations Geordie1 Today, 08:27tattyheedMick's UTD111...
  Mark McGhee Today, 08:26tattyheedNewcastle Uni...
  Poll: Play-Offs 05-19, 12:27Sir Kevin KeeganOther Teams
  It's Started 05-18, 06:34MickNewcastle Uni...
  New strip 05-17, 15:12Geordie1Newcastle Uni...
  Atsu 05-17, 11:49CiatmolNewcastle Uni...
  Villains..... 05-15, 11:22mickyquinnstacheOther Teams
  Club Statement On The Fut... 05-14, 16:05MickNewcastle Uni...
  Rafa v Ashley 05-12, 06:39Geordie1Newcastle Uni...
  New funds 05-10, 17:49GhostfaceKillahNewcastle Uni...
  Mike and his trophies 05-08, 19:21BoydieNewcastle Uni...
  The Rafa Affect 05-08, 11:46CiatmolNewcastle Uni...
  SMB 05-08, 11:24tattyheedThe Dark Side...
  How much? 05-08, 09:19MickNewcastle Uni...
  Champions..... 05-08, 08:01PapillonNewcastle Uni...
  Barnsley (h) 05-07, 13:36GhostfaceKillahNewcastle Uni...
  West Ham 1 Little Totts 0 05-06, 13:30PapillonOther Teams
Top posters
Boydie 11694
Mick 10931
SirLes9 6758
Gos 6510
Sir Kevin Keegan 5928
Pazman 5583
positive pedro 4993
Ciatmol 3958
pboromag 3218
Monty Don 2841
cg40k 2720
mickyquinnstache 2316
arfa the mag 2123
Tinyclanger16 1955
Nige_S4 1685
bluebayou 1637
tattyheed 1569
Michael 1560
Most replies
  January trans... 344
  Summer transf... 290
  Boydie's on t... 258
  Summer transf... 205
  austin off to... 151
  Time for chan... 130
  Bas Dost 129
  the relegatio... 126
  fantasy eleve... 125
  Back Room Tea... 121
  charlie austi... 102
  Toon related ... 98
  newcastle v a... 97
  Season Ticket... 94
  Carroll comin... 93
  Vile v Le Too... 89
  chelski match... 77
  toon v city m... 76

Post Reply 
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Votes - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Safe standing ???
Author Message
Boydie Offline

Posts: 11,694
Joined: Jun 2012
Post: #1
Safe standing ???
Something that hasn't been asked on here.... would you be for or against a safe standing area within St James' Park? If so where and if not why.

Would this be a success and could our very own SirLes (Steve) discuss this issue at the next meeting?
13-03-2017 11:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SirLes9 Offline
Part Of The Furniture

Posts: 6,758
Joined: Jun 2012
Post: #2
RE: Safe standing ???
It's already been a point of discussion mate.
The club are seemingly in favour of it, but can do nothing more without a change in legislation from the FA.

It's a massive point really.

Firstly, the FA will not approve safe standing areas yet, but do not force fans to sit at games. Unsafe standing in my opinion as there is more chance of fans falling over the seats in the current set up.
Rail seating prevents this from happening.

I'm still not too sure how that will work for away fans mind.
Away from home we stand for 90 minutes in the seating areas. Maybe a little unfair on people who want to sit down but that's just the way it goes unfortunately.
As a regular away traveller I know first hand that our fans create a far better atmosphere standing up. Maybe odd to those who just don't get it, but again, that's the way it is.
So you could potentially have a safe standing area for home fans, alongside away fans standing in the seating area. Quite weird really.

I'm part of the "Wor Hyem" fan group, who are pushing for the creation of a singing area within SJP to help improve the failing atmosphere and are in negotiations with the club about it.
Now if that was to happen, fans could move to that section, wherever it may be, and I guess part of that areas criteria will be that fans will stand and sing. Again, in a less safe environment.
It would be hoped that in the event of a safe standing area being granted, then the fans in that proposed "singing section" would get first option to move in to it.

Where would I put a safe standing area? (which I'm obviously in favour of)
Again, difficult. You need somewhere big enough as the whole idea is to help create a better atmosphere. But you also need somewhere that won't interfere with the view of anyone sitting behind such a section.
By the time you remove the seating from the Strawberry corner and replace it with rail seating, that area would then not hold enough fans to make it a worthwhile exercise.
My own suggestion would be the North West Corner. (Milburn-Leazes)
Big enough and in an area that will not spoil anyone else's enjoyment or view.
A similar size to the one recently installed at Celtic.
Areas are currently being discussed for these fan type areas, by senior members of fan groups, but as yet they are pretty hush hush.
That's only fair as people may have to be moved to accommodate them and they need to be informed in the right manner.

Anyone interested in supporting the Wor Hyem fan group, you can sign up here

"We are not a stepping stone, we are Newcastle United. Every player should be honoured to wear the shirt of this club" Rafa Benitez.
14-03-2017 10:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Boydie Offline

Posts: 11,694
Joined: Jun 2012
Post: #3
RE: Safe standing ???
Cheers Steve. yep
14-03-2017 10:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Tinyclanger16 Offline
Thinks outside the box

Posts: 1,955
Joined: Jun 2012
Post: #4
RE: Safe standing ???
I'd love it if we could sort out standing for those who enjoy doing so.

I don't like it as it is where everyone is supposed to sit but gets up every time there's any action near them for a few reasons:
I'm small and if everyone stands up I can't see much!
As things are with the seats, the space to stand is so narrow, I worry I'll fall. I worry much more that big blokes who have had a few jars will fall.....

My fella has a walking stick and is unsteady on one side. He physically cannot stand up for 90 mins. Even standing still for a bit makes him wobble. This means if everyone stands he either sees nothing, or HE might fall!
Maybe he should go in the disabled section, but to be honest, I don't know if he'd qualify.

So as far as I'm concerned, if those who love to stand could go somewhere and stand, that would be brilliant for them and good for us too because not so many will stand in the seats!!

Complicated. scratch
X tc

"I'd rather learn from one bird how to sing than teach ten thousand stars how not to dance." ee cummings, 1894-1962
15-03-2017 08:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SirLes9 Offline
Part Of The Furniture

Posts: 6,758
Joined: Jun 2012
Post: #5
RE: Safe standing ???
One of the biggest stumbling blocks for any standing or singing section is those currently in that proposed area who do not want to be part of it.
Whilst the majority of us (I assume) are in favour of such sections, would you be so keen if it meant you'd have to give your current seat up and move?
The club do not want to force anyone to move, but for the benefit of these groups, they would certainly like people to do so.

Groups like Wor Hyem know that there are thousands of fans, scattered all around the ground, who would be happy to sit/stand together and support the team throughout the game. Pretty much in the way that us away fans do.
But it's no good when you have them all in little pockets in every corner of the ground. They need to be together. Also, those not wanting to be part of it need to move somewhere else. Harsh, but a reality if things are to improve in terms of ground atmosphere.
The current area where a lot of fans moved to, the east corner of the Gallowgate, still has a lot of fans in who do not want to take part. They argue with those who do and therefore the atmosphere can get killed very quickly.

The club needs to support this in every way it can and at the moment things are looking very positive.
Hopefully the standing legislation can be changed soon and that can be the next challenge for our fan groups.

"We are not a stepping stone, we are Newcastle United. Every player should be honoured to wear the shirt of this club" Rafa Benitez.
16-03-2017 08:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 

Forum Jump:

User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)